2.23.20: An Alternative History Story for the Democratic Establishment... Everyone's Getting Berned

Alternative History stories are quite popular these days, seems for good reason, so here is a stark revisionism for the Democratic Party establishment... Not coming to Netflix.


Let's go back to August 2013 when a proven state's attorney general is given a clean bill of health from his doctor and his oncologist and now has his sight set on running for governor in 2016, and in the state of Delaware the election would have been a lock. On the cusp of his 48th birthday, Joseph Robinette Biden III, known as Beau is elected the 74th governor of Delaware.

In the turbulent age of Trump, Governor Biden proves to have been the right choice running his state effectively, growing its income from what turns out in the eyes of all those incorporated there to be a minuscule tax increase. In the face of the president's flouting of the rule of law in this country, the fmr. JAG office speaks out.

Though he's only been a one-term governor, he demonstrates that rare leadership quality, a clear voice of reason that cuts through the fog and carrying himself wise beyond his years. 

February 3, 2019

On his 50th birthday, speaking from the top of the round steps in front of Legislative Hall in the first state of the Union's capital of Dover, Beau Biden announces he's running for president of the United States of America.

Wall Street and business love him because it's Delaware after all, but as a solid Democrat with the Biden name moderates and labor knew exactly where they wanted to go. Because of his father's historically strong support of the African-American community, Beau had their full backing. 

With all this support, he didn't let anyone down presenting himself as the obvious with the rhetorical chops to go with it. Despite the vicious attacks on his family, he successfully fought back and cut through it having clearing the moderate lane in the field with strong seasoned debate performances. 

Bernie Sanders' movement has great momentum and support but it's not enough to overcome the cumulative support garnered by Governor Biden. 

At the Democratic Convention in Milwaukee, Beau Biden accepts the party's nomination as their candidate for president with a soaring speech and gracious words for Senator Sanders who days later gives his full support.

And then...

Standing behind a podium with a BIDEN for PRESIDENT sign, in front of 12,000 people, "Ladies and Gentlemen, the 44th president of the United States of America President Barack Obama.

Game over.

*****

But as it stands, Senator Sanders with a caucus win in Nevada is the clear front runner, and as Dan Pfeiffer explained, it's not too late for a moderate challenge but it's getting pretty close to too late. If Mr. Sanders has a strong showing on Super Tuesday then there's no chance.

However, Mr. Pfeiffer also said that in head-to-head polls Mr. Trump trails Mr. Sanders so if he can 'navigate his vulnerabilities' well he could win.

From the graph, one can see there's legitimate concern across the electorate. Those numbers aren't good, but they're not as bad as they could be.

When you have Hugh Hewitt and James Carville on the same page in terms of the nomination of Bernie Sanders as the general election candidate, there is definitely something wrong. Both feel that it will be a slam dunk reelection win for Trump. Being more refreshingly objective today, Mr. Hewitt thinks the Pete Buttigieg is the strongest to face Trump because he understands middle-small town America.

But it does ring hollow to celebrate second place as Nevada Independent's Jon Ralston explained. Mr. Sanders had a great head start and solidified base before this election cycle and he's running with it, doubling all the other candidates in Nevada.

Obviously, Mike Bloomberg crippled his campaign by rhetorically shooting himself in the foot on the debate stage - woefully prepared - and adding insult to injury he got the proverbial kick square in the nuts from Senator Elizabeth Warren. He has one opportunity coming up to right that.

The only statement you can trust uttered by Marc Short, Chief of Staff for VP Pence, is that the president is comfortable with the state of the Democratic Field.


Panel: Betsy Woodruff Swan, The Daily Beast; Hugh Hewitt, Salem Radio Network; Dan Pfeiffer, "Pod Saves America"; Kimberly Atkins, WBUR in Boston

2.16.20: The Next Two Primary Contests are the Real Clarifiers for Democrats

Lots of good points and dead-on statements were made on today's "Meet The Press" for sure, starting with Vice President Biden's critique of Bernie Sanders. The fmr. VP explained that it's one thing to have ideas, but it's another to get things done. And truth be told, Senator Sanders hasn't gotten much done during his time in the Senate. That is not to say that Senator Sanders ideas are not good or that some version of them can not be passed, but the Vermont Senator hasn't presented them that way. Ideologues in America politics rarely if ever succeed on a national scale. This is just calling as it is seen.

Additionally, Mr. Biden touched an important point that is ever present in our politics where there seems to be no remedy at this point in time and that's the fecklessness on both sides. Mr. Sanders isn't responsible for the personal attacks that his supporters levied online toward the Nevada culinary union leaders, but he has to take some accountability, which he will not do. And then there is Lindsey Graham who is only concerned with maintaining his own position in the Senate, so much so that when the president attacked John McCain, his so-called friend Mr. Graham uttered not a word in his defense. Senator Graham on a consistent basis proves he is no leader and he never will be one. Like many elected officials in his party, the come-to-Jesus moment isn't arriving anytime soon, if at all.

With all that said, this column's opinion that Mr. Biden's window for winning the presidency has passed hasn't changed. To elaborate on that, it's not the attacks from the president on Mr. Biden and his son that the Democratic electorate feel have damaged Mr. Biden's candidacy, it's his lack of a forceful, full-throated response that has disappointed. Conversely, as NBC's Peter Alexander pointed out, despite the criticism of his record and money, Democrats liked the fact that Michael Bloomberg gave it right back to Mr. Trump when the president attacked him. It's not a matter of going low or high or where ever. It's a matter of having fighting back and not letting the president bully you.

Speaking of Mr. Bloomberg, Maria Teresa Kumar asked the pertinent question of which Mr. Bloomberg will show up. Will it be the philanthropist Michael Bloomberg or will it be the Mayor Bloomberg? The philanthropist, as Ms. Kumar outlined, who has given to women's and gun-control organizations is the preference of course. However, Mr. Bloomberg's goal is to meld both into the most positive message. There certainly are difficulties that Mr. Bloomberg will face with regard to his record - 'Stop and Frisk' being at the top of the list. However, as the Washington Post's Eugene Robinson explained, this election is going to be a knife fight certainly like one we've never seen so why shouldn't it the person with the biggest knife for the Democrats? No one on either side is going to match the monetary resources that Mr. Bloomberg brings, but there is a downside that Danielle Pletka pointed out, which is that extreme wealth has an isolating effect on a person. At some point, Mr. Bloomberg is going to have to step out beyond the advertising and choreographed speech appearances. To that end, it's why senator and presidential candidate Amy Klobuchar (D-MN) wants Mr. Bloomberg on the debate stage.

Senator Klobuchar also said that it's necessary for Mr. Bloomberg to appear on programs like "Meet The Press" to answer the difficult questions that he may face. As for Senator Klobuchar's campaign, does she have an encore, as Chuck Todd asked her. It's yet to be seen if she can build on her momentum from the New Hampshire primary, but if you look at all the candidates in the Democratic primary at present, she would be the most formidable challenger to Donald Trump. Maybe she's not on the president's radar for attacks yet, but she is the most difficult to attack and maybe that's why he hasn't done so. She's a Midwest senator will a solid legislative record who garners support from Democrats and moderate Republicans. She has solid bona fides on foreign policy having traveled abroad extensively with John McCain who took her under his wing. She doesn't have the baggage that the president's surrogates can attack, which unfortunately we've already seen from the likes of Rush Limbaugh (The least deserving of the Presidential Medal of Freedom in American history.) who has activated the homophobic dog whistles against Mayor Pete Buttegieg. However, as Ms. Klobuchar admitted, she doesn't have the name recognition that the other candidates do and when it comes to competing in primaries in the south east and west, it's a steep hill to climb.

It's still early and it's anyone's race, but there's no doubt that with Nevada (wish it was a primary instead of a caucus) and South Carolina right around the bend, the writing on the wall will be in permanent ink.


Panel: Eugene Robinson, The Washington Post; Danielle Pletka, American Enterprise Institute; Peter Alexander, NBC; Maria Teresa Kumar, Voto Latino

2.9.20: Still Too Early For Democratic Primary Predictions, However...

In the course of today's "Meet The Press" the issue of President Trump's acquittal in the Senate this week was only briefly touched on in comparison to the discussion of what is going in the Democratic primary.

We'll tackle this first as the question was asked, "What was the lesson that the president learned?" But the more significant question is "what we have learned?" Mr. Trump, as Kasie Hunt pointed out, feels that he can be vindictive as he wants and take any actions he thinks will benefit him, given the Republican-controlled Senate's vote. What have we learned? We've learned that this president is now free to operate above the law as it would apply to an ordinary citizen and that his behavior and methods will not change.

The political fallout in November is still too soon to predict, but one thing is certain and that is  Senator Susan Collins (R-ME) is continually getting played by this president and frankly when she suggests that she hopes Mr. Trump has learned a lesson from all this, she is being hopelessly naive and the streak of independence that she purports to have looks like a joke. At the end of the day, she'll go along with the crowd.

As for the Democrats, even with the Iowa debacle behind them and on the cusp of the New Hampshire primary it is still really too soon to tell who the nominee will be come the general, but right now, the two front runners are Senator Bernie Sanders (I-VT) and fmr. South Bend mayor Pete Buttigieg who Chuck Todd interviewed this morning.

Make no mistake, both would have a very difficult and perhaps improbable road to the White House if either was to become the nominee. Also, for the record, Mr. Todd challenged Mr. Sanders less than he did with Mayor Pete, as he is known.

Mr. Sanders is an ideologue for the left, which being as such, will make it problematic for him to win. Medicare-for-all and other proposals that Mr. Sanders is advocating for sound good, but practically speaking are unattainable. We're not trying to burst anyone's bubble, but looking at pragmatically, the votes will never come to pass such societal changes.

As for Mayor Pete, he takes a much more centrist approach; case in point would be with healthcare and creating a public option within the Affordable Care Act. However, with both of these two candidates, one word comes to mind when thinking of either of them in the general election.

Surrogates.

President Trump will denigrate socialism himself if going up against Mr. Sanders. He's done as much already, but his surrogates will pull out all of the statements he's made from the past 40 years and put Bernie on the defensive for every one of them. Mr. Sanders, corrected Mr. Todd when the moderator posed the notion that people are scared on the word "socialism," calling what he is for is "democratic socialism." It's not going to matter. Middle America doesn't want to be Europe, especially when they find out that they'll have to pay more in taxes to have Medicare-for-all.

During the interview with Pete Buttigieg, Mr. Todd played a clip showing an Iowa woman being told that Mr. Buttigieg is gay and then her saying that she wants to change her vote because of it. Mr. Buttigieg's answer was compassionate inasmuch as he said that he was saddened by the answer but that if he were the president, he would be working hard for her too. The majority of Americans do not take issue with Mr. Buttigieg's private life, but unfortunately, the president's surrogates will know no low when it comes to smearing the fmr. mayor's sexuality. It's this type of harsh reality that the country will have to prepare for, and again, frankly, they're not ready to be so open minded. Sad but true.

As for Joe Biden, he will likely finish fourth again in New Hampshire creating even stronger headwinds for his campaign. Mr. Biden will be in the race until at least super Tuesday, which will be the great determining factor in deciding the nominee. However, one can't help but think that Mr. Biden has missed his window. Objectively, he just hasn't been as sharp as he needs to be this time around to capture the nomination.

And speaking of super Tuesday, with all the talk of the primaries, there is still the candidacy of billionaire and former New York mayor Michael Bloomberg looming over the entire field.  Mr. Bloomberg is putting all his resources into advertising leading up to that day. After super Tuesday, it will become very clear whether Mr. Bloomberg will continue or not. Regarding his resources, i.e. money, Mr. Bloomberg has already spent $273 million dollars on advertising, completely dwarfing the entire field.

Senator Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) has contested that someone should not be able to buy his way into the nomination. However, it's difficult for this column to condemn Mr. Bloomberg for the way he is conducting his campaign because given all the hundreds of millions of dollars in dark money that plays a role in political campaigns, we know that all the money that Mr. Bloomberg has spent is his own. Mr. Buttigieg explained that there is little substitute for retail politics - listening to the electorate and communicating with them face to face - and as Mr. Sanders stated today, campaigns are about more than just money, you still need the message and the votes.

It's too early to make any predictions with the exception that once the general is upon us, Mr. Trump will be sure to make it the ugliest campaign we've ever witnessed.


Panel: Kasie Hunt, NBC News; John E. Sununu; Claire McCaskill, fmr. Senator of Missouri; Joshua Johnson, MSNBC

2.4.20: The Presidential Infommerical... The State of the Union

For the Presidential infommercial... uhhhh... The State of the Union address, we took some notes and added a few reactions. I say it in the notes, but he only spoke to one side of the room. Raw steak anyone?

Walks into the chamber at 9:03.

It will be interesting to see how he will address impeachment, and he certainly will. 

He's not smiling at all. He doesn't look happy.

At the rostrum...

The president didn't shake the House Speaker's hand.

Republicans are chanting "4 more years."

"Our country is highly respected again."

"The years of economic decay are over."

Lots of platitudes into "the state of our union is stronger than ever before."

He's only addressing one side of the room. He's not even looking at the other side.

The failed economic policies of the previous administration. Obama gave him this economy.

7M off food stamps and 10M off welfare, really?

16% wage increase for low income workers since his election.
Blue collar boom.

Kyrsten Sinema stood up for tax cuts.

Tony Rankins - veteran success story.

Regulation reduction campaign.
Mike Pence can't wait to stand up. The vice president has a man-crush on Donald Trump.

Unlike so many before me, I keep my promises. OMG.

China trade... and farmer bailouts.

Socialist Dictator of Venezuela... Maduro's grip will be on power will be coming to an end.
Juan Guaido in the house.

Socialism destroys nations - a shot at Bernie.

Allies are now paying their fair share.

The SPACE FORCE. I'm kind of in for the Space Force. Sounds like a cartoon, but whatever.

The only victories in Washington are the ones that delivery for the American people.

Put America first...

Failing government schools... The knock on public education.
School choice...

Opportunity scholarship, awarded by the president.

No child should be forced to send their child to a failing government school.

The Be Best initiative... Yeah, whatever happened to that? Does the first lady do anything?

Vocational and technical training in every single high school. But where would that training take place? In public high schools.

Healthcare is 60% less expensive and better since he came into office. Huh?

Shot at Medicare for all.

Ban free government healthcare for illegal aliens, but they don't get that now. "A very tall and powerful wall is being built."

There is no fact-checking this in real time, but there is no way he's being honest about any of this.

Rush Limbaugh shot out - diagnosed with stage four cancer. No one has done more to divide America. Don't wish anyone ill will, but...

And now the Presidential Medal of Freedom, please.

Oh brother. Thought this was the State of the Union address.

Asking Congress for the banning late-term abortions.

Paid family leave for government workers - He signed the bill but he didn't want to. He didn't want to give them the money.

We must also build America's infrastructure.

The heroic I.C.E. officers - 120,000+ criminal aliens.
Illegal aliens were responsible for over 2,000 murders?

Going after New York and California for their immigration policies...

My administration has ended catch and release. You will be promptly removed from our country, after your separated from your family.

The Constitutional right to pray in public schools... on if you're a Christian. Keep religion out of the schools.

Second Amendment applause line... Yada yada yada.

It's just weird that reality is so much different than how President Trump describes it.

It's nice that the brought the soldier back, but it's cheap politics. What about the rest of the troops not getting preferential treatment. 

America is a land of heroes... Weird sense of history. Reminiscing about America is very Trump.

He didn't even touch impeachment or anything close to it... Well, that's a relief.

Nancy Pelosi torn up the speech before he even left.

Gov. Gretchen Whitmer (D-MI) gives the Democratic response.

2.2.20: Instructive Iowa Caucuses Against the Backdrop of an Impotent Impeachment

Well, no one said it wouldn't be interesting. First interviews after the Senate's vote to not call for witnesses and documents in the impeachment trial, the Iowa Caucus tomorrow, State of the Union on Tuesday and the final vote in the Senate on Wednesday all mean that it's time to buckle up.

For a change of pace as this column has been wont not to comment on primary politics thus far, for all the noise that has been out there and we've taken the patience to see how things would shake out a bit before weighing in.

For all the complaints about the Iowa Caucuses, for Democrats they will be very instructive this election cycle.

Some argue that Iowa isn't diverse enough to be first and it's not a secret ballot, which as Tom Brokaw explained can cause some people to stay home. However, he also said that Iowans take their citizenship seriously and come out for these, as we all know. The Iowa Caucuses are the last rally for the candidates. They just happen to be all on the same night and they count this time. As today's panel agreed, the Democratic primary is so fluid because of all the factors at work for each candidate, serious citizens in public will provide some good guidance for the rest of the electorate, geography and the Bloomberg factor taken into consideration.

Democratic Strategist Cornell Belcher said with no clear front runner, Biden could finish anywhere from first to fourth. The elephant in the room of course is which candidate has sound proposes but more importantly beat Trump. Of the candidates at the top in Iowa - Biden, Sanders, Warren, Buttigieg and Klobuchar - only three of the five survive the second test against Trump.

The National Review's Rich Lowry described Bernie Sanders as radioactive in terms of the attacks he'll face from conservatives, and he's right. Elizabeth Warren will get crushed in a general election, which leaves us with Biden, Buttigieg and Klobuchar. In Iowa however, Sanders energy may carry the day. This is a scenario where Iowa will be less beneficial as a first stop because if Biden is still in for Super Tuesday, he and Bloomberg will be fighting it out. Anna Palmer from Politico explained that if Biden doesn't do well in Iowa or New Hampshire that could be it for him, with Mr. Lowry adding that Mr. Biden suffers from low enthusiasm. In a general election, enthusiasm ground can be made up with Biden's pick for vice-president, 'steady hand at the top bolstered by high energy.'

With all that said, we can only tell you that Elizabeth Warren will have the most disappointing night of all the previous mentioned.

*****

It turns out that Senator Lamar Alexander's (R-TN) word on impeachment was the really the final one. He explained that there was no need for witnesses and documents because the Democratic House Managers clearly proved that President Trump pressured Ukraine for an investigation of the Bidens by withholding military aid. However, this action doesn't warrant the removal of the president from office with an election about to start. Mr. Alexander went on to say that the public should be the ones to decide.

Senator Alexander's reasoned explanation is understandable, but as Mr. Belcher pointed out it ignores the moral obligation to the Constitution and the rule of law, which is where we should all land. The president broke the law and he knew he was doing it. At one point Mr. Alexander said that maybe Mr. Trump didn't know not to do what he did, which is inexcusable to use as an excuse, especially at this point given the entire Russia investigation and the fact that Mr. Trump spoke with the Ukrainian president the day after Robert Mueller testified. What we will come to learn is that information will come out that confirms why the president could not be removed. EU Ambassador Gordan Sondland's statement "that everyone was in the loop" will prove correct.

But there you have it. The acquittal will be on Wednesday. The Tennessee senator recommended that during the State of the Union, the president shouldn't mention it at all, but something tells us that Mr. Trump won't be able to hold back in front of a national audience.

Mr. Lowry questioned why if impeachment is such a moral obligation then why haven't Iowa voters been talking about it, to which O. Kay Henderson, Iowa Radio News Director, responded that because of the foregone conclusion of what the Senate would do, there wasn't the need. Everyone knows where the Democratic candidates stand on it. Despite Mr. Lowry sophomoric observation, the impeachment vote and the Republican rollover will be a factor come the general election in November.

If many Republican senators feel the same as Mr. Alexander, maybe a censure of the president is called for - the proverbial slap on the wrist. Censure would be a win for Democrats. Not only could they say that the trial was a sham because Republicans didn't fulfill their obligation, but then they can also say that Republicans admit what the president did was wrong because of censure. That would have the president sniping at Republican Senators who are in enough trouble trying to hold onto their seats, just as Ms. Henderson said of Senator Joni Ernst in Iowa.


Panel: O. Kay Henderson, News Director Radio Iowa; Anna Palmer, Politico; Rich Lowry, The National Review; Cornell Belcher, Democratic Strategist

One more thing...
Can't forget about the Super Bowl - Andy Reid gets the championship, Chiefs all the way!